4.26.2006

Ratios and music

I've been reading Harry Partch lately. Great stuff. It became much more enjoyable after I printed my GRE vocab list and kept it nearby. Here is my book report on Partch's Genesis of a Music: This guy is neurotic.

I respect the work that he put into this stuff and all, it's just that he is overly thorough. The sad part is that his invented instruments are now quite obsolete as a result of technology.

Anyway here is the start of what may become a series of posts based on intonation.

Ratios.
Music is most correctly described as ratios. All those lines and dots and squiggles that is all the rage in today's music conservatories are misleading, erroneous, artificial, cumbersome... oh, don't get me started on notation.

The first rule of ratio music is two's are perceived as the same note. Tell a choir to sing an "A," the altos with perfect pitch, that is, all of them, will sing A440, which is a tone that vibrates at 440 times a second. The tenors will sing A220, the basses will sing A110, and the divas among the sopranos, that is, the entire soprano section will sing A880. 110, 220, 440, and 880. Halved or doubled, they're all the same note, just different octaves.

Now through a convoluted and arbitrary historical process that will wait for another day for thorough explanation, an octave on the piano contains 12 chromatic keys. This equally tempered scale is a perversion of the ratios that occur naturally in sound. The mindset behind equal temperament is, "Well, since its too hard to get most of the notes in tune, we'll just make all of them out of tune and they'll be close enough."

As a result, none of the ratios that you hear on a "well" tuned piano occur naturally except for the octave, the 2 to 1 ratio. Some knot-head about 500 years ago said to himself, "Hey, let's just forget about these inconvenient ratios and divide the octave into 12 equal segments."

Then he said. "That makes cents."

4.12.2006

Sound and performance

One characteristic of electronic music is the way the music is divorced from the performance gesture. That is, the sound does not necessarily relate to the performance of that sound. For instance, watch Bela Fleck and his Flecktones sometime. You'll hear percussion though there is no apparent drummer on stage. The percussionist is actually Future Man, playing his drum axe, or whatever he calls it, wait, let me check... "synth-axe drumitar." It's basically a guitar like thing with a whole lot of buttons all over it, triggering whatever drum samples he programs for each song. It makes sense to me, he has ten fingers to work with instead of just four limbs. Also the bassist, Victor Wooten, doesn't appear to play half the notes you hear, but that's not electronics, that's just crazy-mad skill.

Whereas in the past a violinist creates a beautiful tone by applying the precise amount of pressure at a carefully consistent speed, today I re-create the same beautiful tone quality by choosing an appropriate sample from my hard drive. However, the point of electronic music is not to duplicate traditional (obsolete) instrumentation, but to expand the sound palette to include entirely new sounds(John Cage, Silence, pg. 4). Who needs mallets and bows and air pressure when the crack of thunder or crashing ocean wave is at my command. Why limit myself to chord progressions to intensify drama when I can include the sound of a wailing child, or exploding rocket. I can be as subtle as the beating of a butterfly's wings or the crackle of smoldering charcoal (Iannis Xenakis, Concret PH, 1958) .

But, the question remains, is all this a good thing? Perhaps the thing that makes music the most valuable for most people is the human connection between audience and performer. People like to visualize (auralize) the rosin contacting the string, the desperate breath required for the trumpet entrance, the effort involved in maintaining pitch on the oboe, etc..

This is why I believe, as much I value electronic music, live performance on acoustic instruments will never completely go away.

3.28.2006

Another idea taken

I think the choir is a sadly untapped resource as far as sound capabilities. I mean imagine the variety of sounds that someone like Bobby Mcferrin can accomplish with his voice and multiply it by 60. Endless possibilities. It highlights one of the true challenges of composition, perhaps the greatest challenge: imagining and sculpting a sound that has never been heard before. This is why I like composing electronic music, I experiment with sounds, move them around stumble on something great and then craft the work. How I wish I had a choir in my basement, on which I could call to try out new ideas: "Okay, altos I want you to click your tongue against your front teeth randomly, tenors sustain an 's' sound according to this notation...." Now you have some understanding what the term "Experimental" means when it comes to early twentieth century composition.

Now to illustrate some of the possibilities of "choral sound-design."
and for those of us with dial up, some .mov, and .wmv files here.
check out the "making of" videos on this blog as well.

3.23.2006

The Dayjob

So I stumbled across Sequenza 21 a couple months ago and have been a fan ever since. So here I am, fresh out of grad school with a degree in composition looking at a blog featuring an experienced contemporary composer. This is what I read: (paraphrased) Don't get a BM in composition. Get a worthwhile degree, a decent job and compose nights and weekends.

Wow. So much for all my dreams and lofty hopes. So much for all that tuition I paid and continue to pay...

When I think about it, though, perhaps he has a point. I mean having a day job might be ideal for a composer. If I want my music to be truly independent, my own voice, then I should not rely on others to pay me according to how much they like the sound. I don't need to have credentials and publications and awards in order to write great music. Someday I will plunge into the highly competitive world of academia, but not right now.

When I was an undergrad, I told a professor I was interested in teaching higher education someday. He said, "Well, someone's gotta do it."

I didn't understand what he meant at the time, but after helping my supervising prof get her tenure, and witnessing the irrelevant hurdles required, I think I know exactly what he meant.

So that's where I'm at. I'm helping my dad with his small business in a small town in rural Pennsylvania. I have composed more things in the last six months that I like personally than I composed in my final year at school. I spend quality time with my wife, daughter and newborn son.

Mission accomplished, so far.
I'll keep you posted.

3.08.2006

Between the Lines

When I was recording my flute and electronics piece, Oasis, I fell in love with the sound of cracked notes, and the unintentional whistle tones produced when the flutist played extremely quietly. As I mixed the piece I tended to emphasize the breath sounds and all of these other "noises" that inevitably occur with live playing. I know the reason I was drawn to these sounds so much... normally in my electronic world they are absent. So much of my time in mixing and recording my files is spent on the making it sound like a realistic performance, adding the imperfect human element. Detuning, adding noise, finessing the vibrato and performance techniques.
Since then I have based entire compositions on these often unwanted sounds or "noises." My Digital Construction suite includes sounds of a bowed violin. Don't get the wrong impression though, I bowed every surface of the violin except for the normal position. The strings behind the bridge, the strings by the posts (listen to the end of #2, it sounds like a creaky swing-set) the bridge itself, the neckpiece, the posts etc...
I like to think of these sounds as those which are beyond the notation, impractical to place on the lines, between the cracks of our steadfast notation system:
Between the lines.

3.05.2006

About me

I compose Electro-acoustic music.
You can listen to some of it here:
www.tedsmoker.com

Thanks for reading,
Ted Smoker